Art Hostage Services
-
The Art Hostage team undertakes a wide range of services, including due diligence, collection conservation and management, risk assessment and security as well as legal issues, recovery and dispute resolution involving art and artifacts. Through partnerships with leading organizations, the Art Hostage team can provide a complete service for all aspects of collecting and protecting art.
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Stolen Art Watch, Moore The Merrier, Marinello Makes Waves As 7ft Standing Figure Goes Walkabout, Moore, Much Henry Moore
Three men hunted over theft of £3million Henry Moore statue from Stewartry estate
Police say the suspects were seen with a Ford Transit van, described as
an “unusual shade of blue”, near the “Standing Figure” at Glenkiln
reservoir.
-
A distinctive van may hold the key to the theft of a world famous £3 million statue from a Stewartry estate.
The Ford Transit, described as an “unusual shade of blue”, was
spotted twice in the vicinity of Henry Moore’s “Standing Figure” at
Glenkiln reservoir.
It
was first seen a week before the theft and witnesses have told police
three men, with the van at the time, were studying the statue.
The Transit was also seen in the area on Friday, around the time of the theft.
Yesterday
the man leading the hunt for the sculpture, Detective Inspector Colin
Burnie, revealed one of the men seen with the van had ginger, shaven
hair and was wearing a red or orange waterproof jacket.
The trio, all in their 20s or 30s, had a collie dog with them.
DI
Burnie said: “We are delighted with the response from the public so far
in this investigation, which has helped us immensely. We now require
further help to identify this blue van and occupants and would again ask
the public to call us if they have any information which may help us.”
-
The Standing Figure by Henry Moore
Galloway News
The seven foot tall “Standing Figure” was one of four Henry Moore statues on display in Lincluden park, near Shawhead.
The world renowned “King and Queen” is one of the others alongside
pieces by Auguste Rodin and Jacob Epstein which complete the set the
late Sir William Keswick put together between 1951 and 1976.
Some of the remaining statues have now been removed for safekeeping.
DI
Burnie added: “The sculpture is one of six on public display and as well
as the monetary worth, it has great emotional and sentimental value
to the family.
“We feel for
Sir Henry Keswick who has continued to display the sculptures outdoors
for all to see, despite them previously being damaged, and to now have
one stolen is sickening.”
Director
of The Henry Moore Foundation, Richard Calvocoressi, said: “The Henry
Moore Foundation is deeply saddened by the theft of the Henry Moore
bronze, ‘Standing Figure’ from the Glenkiln Estate.
“We
profoundly sympathise with the owners of this important sculpture, which
was purchased directly from Moore by Sir William Keswick and sited
on his estate, a spectacular setting which pleased Moore immensely.”
The statue was valued at around £3million in 2008.
Police
are keeping an open mind whether it was stolen for its scrap metal value
or in a “fairly daring raid” due to its value as a work of art.
The
sculpture park is a popular visitor attraction and tourism bosses are hoping the theft won’t put people off visiting the area.
Paula
McDonald, regional director of VisitScotland, said: “We are extremely
disappointed at what has happened to the ‘Standing Figure’ and we hope
that it is safely recovered and returned to its rightful place.
“While
the hopefully temporary absence of the sculptures is a great shame, we
would expect visitors to continue to enjoy the region’s array of
beautiful landscapes and attractions.”
Christopher Marinello Art Loss Register Director Sets Up Rival Firm
Christopher Marinello, Art Loss Register
Christopher Marinello Art Loss Register Director Sets Up Rival FirmThe ALR, the world’s largest private
database of lost and stolen art, antiques and collectables is about to
have some competition. Christopher Marinello the Director General
Counsel for the company is leaving to set up his own rival firm, after
seven years service.been a lawyer since 1986,
specialising in resolving art related title disputes. Marinello who is
also a lawyer said in a recent interview, "The Art Loss Register and I
have been a good fit for the last seven years".
The
ALR's range of services have included item registration, search and
recovery services to collectors, the art trade, insurers and worldwide
law enforcement agencies. These services are delivered by employing art
IT technology and a team of specially trained professional art
historians. The worldwide team has been deliberately constructed so as
to offer a range of language capabilities as well as specialities
(modern art, old masters, antiquities).
Conceptually, there are
two aspects to the business. First, by encouraging both the registration
of all items of valuable possessions on the database and also the
expansion of checking searches, the ALR acts as a significant deterrent
on the theft of art. Criminals are now well aware of the risk, which
they face in trying to sell on stolen pieces of art.
Second, by
operating a due diligence service to sellers of art and also being the
worldwide focus for any suspicion of illegitimate ownership, the ALR
operates a recovery service to return works of art to their rightful
owners. In recent years, the service has been extended to negotiate
compensation to the victims of art theft and a legitimising of current
ownership.
The ALR’s pre-eminence in the field of stolen art has
allowed the business to be instrumental in the recovery of over £160m
($320m, €230m) worth of stolen items.
In a recent letter
Marinello stated; "I am pleased to announce that after 7 years as
General Counsel for the Art LossRegister, I have left the company to
form Art Recovery International, a London based partnership that
specialises in recovering stolen, missing, and looted works of art. I
have assembled a small team of legal experts and other professionals who
offer discreet and bespoke services to collectors, dealers, insurers,
museums and artists.
While our primary focus is on art recovery
and resolving complex title disputes, we also provide due diligence
services and provenance research. We will be active in education on art
crime and cultural heritage preservation and plan on instituting a pro
bono service for artists, eligible claimants, and non-profit
institutions.
We are also working with a number of developers to
build what will be the most comprehensive central database of stolen and
looted artwork, title disputes, fakes and forgeries, and works that may
be subject to financial security interests. Utilising the most advanced
technology available, the database will be run ethically, responsibly
and with respect for the rule of law.
This is the ground floor of
a very exciting business. I am open-minded to ideas and policies and
recognize that all of you have either years of experience or youthful
brilliance to impart. I welcome and appreciate both and thank you in
advance for your support".
Unholy €25K art heist in Limerick shocks priests
Stripped bare: Fr Tom Ryan stands in
front of one the frames where the paintings were cut out with a stanley
knife, in the Holy Rosary church on the Ennis Road, where the theft
occurred. Picture: Michael Cowhey
PRAYERS were said at the weekend for the
return of five paintings stolen from the Holy Rosary church in Limerick,
which are estimated to be worth at least €25,000.
The religious paintings by the renowned artist the late
Fr Jack Hanlon had been hanging proudly in the Ennis Road church for
over 50 years.
But on Wednesday last - some 20 minutes after Fr
Tom Ryan left the church - a thief with a newspaper covering his face
entered the church and cut the five paintings out of their frames with a
stanley knife.
Chief Superintendent Dave Sheahan said they are
appealing for the public’s assistance in this case, and will be
circulating images of the stolen works to alert the public and any
potential buyers.
“People are very shocked, as indeed am I,” said Fr William Walsh.
“It’s
a dreadful and very unfortunate thing to happen. We had 100 people at
mass on Thursday morning and people were very distressed and annoyed. At
first some people thought the paintings had been removed for
restoration,” he told the Limerick Leader.
Measuring about three
feet long by five feet wide, the works were valued at €5,000 each when
they were assessed by a local evaluator in 2010.
However, it’s
understood they could be worth considerably more, as one work by Dublin
born Fr Hanlon, who died in 1968, recently sold for as much as six times
that figure in the United States.
His work was recently featured
in an exhibition in the Irish Museum of Modern Art (IMMA) in Dublin,
which went on to tour the country.
The paintings depict St
Patrick, St Brigid, St Oliver Plunkett, Jesus in the carpenter’s shop
with the Holy Family, and Pope Pius IX.
“People are very upset by
this, especially our older parishioners who remember when the paintings
were first mounted in the church,” said Fr Ryan.
“It’s hard to know what they could do with them. It’s a big shock.”
The theft is believed to have occurred at about 12.50pm.
The paintings were specifically painted for the church by Fr Hanlon after it opened in 1950.
The
famous art collector John Hunt introduced the artist to Monsignor
Michael Moloney, a parish priest who later became Diocesan secretary to
successive bishops of Limerick, and who had a great interest in history
and the arts. Hunt encouraged a number of artists at the time to
contribute to the decoration of the church, and also loaned items from
his own collection to the church for its opening.
Art dealers have been informed of the theft.
The 27-by-20-inch Basquiat drawing that was auctioned for more than $600,000 at Christies
Back off my Basquiat!
A Manhattan man claims he is the rightful owner of a Jean-Michel
Basquiat drawing that raked in $627,000 at a Christie’s auction.
Francesco Pellizzi, 73, says his mother paid $8,800 for the
27-by-20-inch work in December 1988, and gave it to him as a Christmas
present.
The Upper East Sider reported the artwork stolen when he realized it
was missing from the file drawer where he kept it, according to his
lawyer, Peter Stern in 2000, said his lawyer, Peter Stern.
Pellizzi didn’t know the fate of the piece until he cracked open a
Christie’s catalogue this year and saw it among the lots ready to be
sold off, according to a Manhattan Supreme Court lawsuit filed last
month.
Thaddeus Stauber, a lawyer for Vorbach, called Pellizzi’s claim “belated” and said he expects it to be dismissed.
He contacted Christie’s, but eventually agreed to let the current
owners, Chicago lawyer David Ruttenberg and art dealer Jennifer Vorbach,
sell the art and allow Christie’s to hold the funds until the ownership
dispute could be decided, according to court papers.
Pellizzi, Ruttenberg and Vorbach were unable to settle their
differences on their own, so Pellizzi is asking a judge to step in and
award him $520,000 of the proceeds — the amount of the winning bid.
“It changed hands a number of times, but Vorbach and Ruttenberg are
not able to trace it back to anyone who obtained it from Mr. Pellizzi,”
Stern said.
The Basquiat in dispute, which portrays a weird, wobbly stick figure,
“has a very long history of life outside the United States where the
laws are different,” Ruttenberg told The Post.
The attorney paid six figures for the piece in 2012, which Vorbach located in a Swiss gallery, he said.
They’d researched the ownership of the art going back about a decade,
and found it had gone through owners in Europe and China before they
came upon it.
“If it’s being sold around Europe, you’re not doing a very good job
of looking for your artwork,” Ruttenberg quipped. “We bought it as an
innocent buyer.”
He declined to name the exact purchase price but said it was less than what the work fetched at auction.
Pellizzi “has no proof of ownership. We’ve never seen any proof his mother gave it to him,” said Ruttenberg.
“That’s what courts are for,” he said of the dispute.
$1 million Norman Rockwell painting goes missing in Queens
The
work was about to be shipped to its new owner when workers discovered
it had been pinched. The oil painting shows a fisherman in a yellow
raincoat braving the drops in a rowboat as he holds a fishing pole.
'Sport,' the missing Norman Rockwell oil on canvas.
Color it gone.
An art thief has swiped a pricey piece of Americana — a Norman Rockwell painting valued at more than $1 million — from a Queens storage facility, cops said.
Workers at Welpak Art Moving and Storage at 58-60 Grand Ave. in
Ridgewood realized the painting, titled “Sport,” was missing at 7 p.m.
Sept. 13.
RELATED: PICASSO, MATISSE, MONETS STOLEN FROM MUSEUM
The work was about to be shipped to its new owner, but workers discovered it had been pinched, cops said.
The 22-by-28 canvas oil painting shows a fisherman in a yellow raincoat
braving the drops in a rowboat as he holds a fishing pole. The painting
is — or was — secured in a gold-colored wooden frame.
Rockwell’s signature appears in the water in the lower right corner of
the painting that once graced the cover of the Saturday Evening Post.
TIRANA, Albania (AP) — Albanian police have seized more than 1,000
religious and secular pieces of art dating from the 15th to the mid-20th
century that were stolen from churches and cultural centers in Albania
and neighboring Macedonia.
Prime Minister Edi Rama, who began his career as an artist, inspected the works and praised police for recovering them.
The
thefts involved 1,077 icons, frescoes and other pieces, and two men
suspected of planning to sell them abroad were arrested, a police
statement said Wednesday.
After a four-month investigation, the
works were found in two houses in the capital, Tirana, where the arrests
took place late Tuesday. Officials did not provide an estimate of the
items' value.
Culture Ministry spokeswoman Milena Selimi said the
looted art was probably headed for sale in other Balkan countries or in
Western Europe.
The recovered works were being kept at the
National Gallery of Arts in Tirana, where experts will examine them and
restore damaged ones.
Cultural authorities say much of the
country's religious heritage remains at risk due to limited resources in
a country where religion was banned for decades under communism.
Rama urged Albanians to help stop the plundering of religious icons.
"What
little we have we must protect," said Rama, himself a painter. He made
his name in politics as a mayor of Tirana who led a campaign to paint
the drab apartment block facades with bright colors.
"If we lose this wealth, our history will vanish with it."
POLICE
in India have confirmed a 1000-year-old statue on display at the Art
Gallery of NSW was stolen from a temple in southern India, most likely
in 2002, increasing the likelihood that a slew of antiquities in
Australia's pre-eminent art galleries will have to be surrendered.
AGNSW director Michael Brand has also confirmed his gallery
has joined the National Gallery of Australia in officially co-operating
with the international investigation into alleged antiquities-smuggling
mastermind Subhash Kapoor.
- See more at:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/arts/visual-arts/agnsw-statue-stolen-from-temple/story-fn9d3avm-1226736454533#sthash.1iIPR2aD.dpuf
Five-year restoration of masterpiece to reveal art mystery
SPLIT, STOLEN, EVEN stashed in a salt mine, one of the world’s most
mythical oils, Flemish masterpiece “The Adoration of the Mystic Lamb”,
is undergoing its most ambitious clean-up in 600 years.
By Flemish primitive masters (and brothers) Hubert and Jan Van Eyck –
though Hubert remains something of a mystery – the 24-panel work is
also known as the Ghent Altarpiece or Lamb of God, and features the
first known nudes in Flemish art, Adam and Eve.
Its unusually eventful past as well as questions over its genesis
pose an extra challenge to the five-year restoration project taking
place in full public view at the Ghent Fine Arts museum (MSK), with
details also on website closertovaneyck.kikirpa.be.
“We’ll never find the exact original state, it just isn’t possible!” project leader Livia Depuydt-Elbaum told AFP.
“With time, colours fade, materials alter. But we can get closer than has ever been possible before.” Early hidden sketch under layers of paint
After a year at work, state-of-the-art analysis has also shown that
the wood in two panels was carved out of the same tree. Infrared
reflectography has revealed an early sketch hidden under layers of
paint.
“It is a much finer work than ever said before, which uses extremely
complex painting techniques,” said art historian Helene Dubois after
poring over St John the Baptist’s robe with a special 3-D microscope at
the Ghent museum.
Visitors to the museum in the Belgian city can see the work in progress behind a large glass panel.
King Filip and Queen Mathilde of Belgium visits the Mystic Lamb altarpiece. (Image: Pool Lieven Van Assche/Belga/PA Images)
Already the iconic Van Eyck reds and greens, the optical effects
and mastery of detail such as fabric patterns and jewels are emerging
from beneath old dulled varnishes.
How long did it take to complete?
Hopes are that the €1.2 million project will clear up questions about
the creation of the work – how long it took to complete, which of the
brothers or their assistants painted what?
Little is known about the Van Eyck family and although Jan’s works
are famous, not a single painting has been attributed with certainty to
Hubert. Some even doubt his existence.
“We have noticed huge differences in painting technique,” said
Dubois. “There are very big differences in quality not only between the
panels but also between different parts of one panel.”
In the first months, conservationists researched the work’s chaotic
history before painstakingly scraping off coats and coats of yellowing
varnish and layers of over-paint at a rate of just four square
centimetres a day.
“All in all there are no catastrophic gaps, no faces or key elements
have been badly damaged or attacked,” said Depuydt-Elbaum. The worst
problem area is a large white spot in St John the Evangelist’s robe, she
said.
That panel was either badly restored in the past or left too close to
a window in the almost 100 years the work spent in a Berlin museum,
where its side panels were sawn apart to separate back and front. From its start, the talk of Europe
Made of 12 oak panels painted on both sides, the massive altarpiece
from its beginnings was the talk of Europe, attracting kings and queens
to St Bavo’s cathedral in Ghent – even German artist Albrecht Durer made
the trip in 1521.
According to letters etched into the frame that make up a chronogram
in Roman numerals, the immense 4.4 x 3.4-metre work dates to 1432 –
although art historians squabble about whether it was really finished by
then.
Image: AP Photo/Yves Logghe, File
The red capital letters are part of a four-line verse stating that
Hubert Van Eyck, “a greater man than whom cannot be found,” began the
work, but that it was completed by Jan, “the second greatest artist.”
With the Reformation, Protestants attacked Ghent in the 16th century
and the altarpiece was hauled up to safety in the St Bavo tower.
Two centuries later, panels that had been seized by the French were
returned to the church by the Duke of Wellingon after his victory at
Waterloo against Napoleon. The nudity was a moral shocker at the time
Ghent sold them not long after to an art dealer – with the exception
of the Adam and Eve panels whose nudity was a moral shocker at the time –
from where they wound up in the hands of the king of Prussia before
heading home.
In 1934, two of the panels were stolen in Ghent and one – The Just Judges – remains missing to this day. Nazis hid it in a salt mine
Sent to the Vatican for protection during World War II, the panels
went instead to France and were seized by the Nazis, who later hid them
in a salt mine in Austria.
There they were saved from planned destruction by the 3rd US Army.
Art historian and restorer Dubois said she first saw the work at age 15 and was transfixed.
“It inspired me to become who I am,” she said.
“After 600 years, this work has not yet delivered all its secrets.”
'Nazi loot' is in major National Gallery show
Specialist in tracking of stolen artworks says curators must not return Klimt portrait to Austria
An unfinished portrait by Gustav Klimt used as the centrepiece of the
National Gallery's major new exhibition is loot stolen by the Nazis,
according to a leading expert. The painting of Amalie Zuckerkandl, which
the Austrian was working on when he died in 1918, is the centrepiece of
the museum's show Facing the Modern: The Portrait in Vienna in 1900,
which runs until January. It is on loan from the Belvedere Gallery in
Vienna, which received it as a gift from a private collector.
E Randol Schoenberg is a Los Angeles-based lawyer who specialises in
the restitution of significant artwork and has won a number of
high-profile cases relating to the recovery of stolen art, particularly
during the Holocaust. He outlined his concerns about the over the
Zuckerkandl painting last week.
"Gustav Klimt's beautiful
unfinished portrait of Amalie Zuckerkandl, herself a Nazi victim, was
owned by Amalie's friend, the Jewish sugar baron Ferdinand Bloch-Bauer.
In 1938, Ferdinand was forced to flee Austria, and survived the war in
Zurich. He died in 1945. As he explained in his will, his 'entire
property in Vienna [had been] confiscated and sold off'. His heirs never
found the portrait."
Mr Schoenberg said the painting was still at
Bloch-Bauer's home nine months after he fled, and that a Nazi inventory
in 1939 listed the work. Dr Erich Führer, a lawyer and high-ranking SS
officer, was initially hired by Bloch-Bauer to protect his property, but
ultimately became the liquidator. According to Mr Schoenberg, he kept
12 of Bloch-Bauer's paintings, including a Klimt, for himself. Mr
Schoenberg said: "No one knows exactly what Dr Führer did with the
portrait, but Amalie's son-in-law supposedly came into possession of it
during the war and sold it to the art dealer Vita Künstler. Vita held on
to the painting for many years, donating it to the Austrian gallery
when she died in 2001."
In 2006, an arbitration panel granted
ownership of the Zuckerkandl portrait to the state, but a dispute over
the decision continues.
In the same year, Mr Schoenberg
successfully represented 90-year-old Maria Altmann in her effort to win
back five stolen Klimt paintings from the state of Austria that had been
seized by the Nazis, including his famous gold portrait of
Bloch-Bauer's wife and Maria's aunt, Adele. It sold for $135m (£83.54m)
later that year, with Mr Schoenberg reportedly earning $120m after the
paintings were sold, having acted on a "no win, no fee" basis.
Mr
Schoenberg concluded on his blog: "The portrait of Amalie is a
Nazi-looted painting, wrongly withheld by the arbitration panel. Under
Austrian law, as it is currently being interpreted, the painting would
be returned to Ferdinand's heirs.
"Perhaps before the National
Gallery returns the painting to the Austrian gallery, it should request a
new determination by the Austrian art restitution advisory board. That
way, this misappropriated painting can finally be returned."
A
spokeswoman for the National Gallery said it had "both legal and ethical
obligations to ensure a work can be borrowed for an exhibition" as well
as international agreements with which it has to comply. She said:
"Klimt's Portrait of Amalie Zuckerkandl is among those paintings in
Facing the Modern for which the Government offers immunity from
seizure. Therefore, the National Gallery has been obliged to investigate
the history of these paintings."
E Randol Schoenberg is a Los Angeles-based lawyer who specialises in
the restitution of significant artwork and has won a number of
high-profile cases relating to the recovery of stolen art, particularly
during the Holocaust. He outlined his concerns about the over the
Zuckerkandl painting last week.
"Gustav Klimt's beautiful
unfinished portrait of Amalie Zuckerkandl, herself a Nazi victim, was
owned by Amalie's friend, the Jewish sugar baron Ferdinand Bloch-Bauer.
In 1938, Ferdinand was forced to flee Austria, and survived the war in
Zurich. He died in 1945. As he explained in his will, his 'entire
property in Vienna [had been] confiscated and sold off'. His heirs never
found the portrait."
Mr Schoenberg said the painting was still at
Bloch-Bauer's home nine months after he fled, and that a Nazi inventory
in 1939 listed the work. Dr Erich Führer, a lawyer and high-ranking SS
officer, was initially hired by Bloch-Bauer to protect his property, but
ultimately became the liquidator. According to Mr Schoenberg, he kept
12 of Bloch-Bauer's paintings, including a Klimt, for himself. Mr
Schoenberg said: "No one knows exactly what Dr Führer did with the
portrait, but Amalie's son-in-law supposedly came into possession of it
during the war and sold it to the art dealer Vita Künstler. Vita held on
to the painting for many years, donating it to the Austrian gallery
when she died in 2001."
In 2006, an arbitration panel granted
ownership of the Zuckerkandl portrait to the state, but a dispute over
the decision continues.
In the same year, Mr Schoenberg
successfully represented 90-year-old Maria Altmann in her effort to win
back five stolen Klimt paintings from the state of Austria that had been
seized by the Nazis, including his famous gold portrait of
Bloch-Bauer's wife and Maria's aunt, Adele. It sold for $135m (£83.54m)
later that year, with Mr Schoenberg reportedly earning $120m after the
paintings were sold, having acted on a "no win, no fee" basis.
Mr
Schoenberg concluded on his blog: "The portrait of Amalie is a
Nazi-looted painting, wrongly withheld by the arbitration panel. Under
Austrian law, as it is currently being interpreted, the painting would
be returned to Ferdinand's heirs.
"Perhaps before the National
Gallery returns the painting to the Austrian gallery, it should request a
new determination by the Austrian art restitution advisory board. That
way, this misappropriated painting can finally be returned."
A
spokeswoman for the National Gallery said it had "both legal and ethical
obligations to ensure a work can be borrowed for an exhibition" as well
as international agreements with which it has to comply. She said:
"Klimt's Portrait of Amalie Zuckerkandl is among those paintings in
Facing the Modern for which the Government offers immunity from
seizure. Therefore, the National Gallery has been obliged to investigate
the history of these paintings."
Antiques and Tiffany crystal stolen in Falls
NIAGARA FALLS – More than $4,000 worth of antiques and collectibles
were stolen from a house in the 8700 block of Pershing Avenue between 5
p.m. Tuesday and 5 p.m. Wednesday, said police.
The 70-year-old
owner told police he noticed some things had been moved and found that a
Tiffany bowl and plate, a pocket watch and parts, costume jewelry, and
Victorian candle holders with a dragon valued at over $2,500, were
stolen; and an antique Chinese trunk was damaged. He said other items
were missing from boxes, but he couldn’t remember what was taken. Total
loss was estimated $4,050.
Police said a large number of boxes were stacked throughout the house.
Ex-Imelda Marcos aide on trial in NYC for selling Monet work
STOLEN,
SOLD Claude Monet’s “L’ Eglise de Vetheuil,” shown here in a photo
supplied by the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office in New York, was
sold for $32 million by former Imelda Marcos’ social secretary, Vilma
Bautista. The buyer said he bought the stolen artwork “in good faith”
and has agreed to a $10-million settlement with the counsel of martial
law victims.
NEW YORK—A debt-ridden onetime aide to Imelda Marcos wrongly sold a
hidden treasure: a $32 million Monet painting the former Philippine
first lady had acquired and her country wants back, prosecutors said
Wednesday as the ex-assistant’s conspiracy trial opened.
In a New York courtroom, Vilma Bautista is facing charges that
invoke the tangled history of Philippine officials’ efforts to reclaim
items from Marcos and her late husband, former President Ferdinand
Marcos.
Bautista is accused of scheming to sell the artwork—part of the
French Impressionist’s famed “Water Lilies” series—and trying to peddle
other valuable paintings that prosecutors say she had no right to sell.
The artwork vanished amid Ferdinand Marcos’ 1986 ouster, ended up in
Bautista’s hands and is part of a multibillion-dollar roster of property
the Philippines claims the Marcoses acquired with the nation’s cash,
prosecutors said.
But for all the art-world intricacies and Philippine politics,
“at bottom, this case is really quite simple—it’s about greed and
fraud,” Manhattan Assistant District Attorney Garrett Lynch told jurors
in an opening statement.
The defense said Bautista believed that
Imelda Marcos rightfully owned the paintings and that Bautista had
authority to sell them for her. Bautista is just an intermediary who got
caught up in a decades-long dispute between a nation and its former
leader, attorney Susan Hoffinger said.
“That battle doesn’t belong here” in a Manhattan criminal courtroom, Hoffinger said in her opening.
After ruling the Philippines with an iron
fist for two decades, Ferdinand Marcos was forced by a “people power”
revolt into exile in Hawaii. He died three years later.
Philippine officials say Marcos and his
associates looted the country’s treasury to amass between $5 billion and
$10 billion. The nation’s Presidential Commission on Good Government
has seized a number of companies, bank accounts and other assets
suspected of being part of that wealth. The Marcoses denied their wealth
was ill-gotten.
Unscathed
With a massive collection of shoes, Imelda
Marcos became a symbol of excess. But she has emerged relatively
unscathed from hundreds of legal cases against her and her late husband,
and she is now a congresswoman in the Philippines.
She’s not expected to testify at Bautista’s trial.
Bautista was a foreign service officer
assigned to the Philippine Mission to the United Nations and later
served as Imelda Marcos’ New York-based personal secretary.
By 2009, Bautista was deep in debt. She
began looking to sell four paintings the Marcoses had acquired during
the presidency—including Monet’s 1899 “Le Bassin aux Nymphease,” also
known as “Japanese Footbridge over the Water-Lily Pond at Giverny,”
prosecutors said.
Bautista ultimately sold the water lily
painting for $32 million to a Swiss buyer, Lynch said. Some proceeds
went to Bautista’s relatives and associates and to debts; $15 million
stayed in her bank accounts, while Imelda Marcos knew nothing of the
sale, the prosecutor said.
Bautista had a 1991 “certificate of
authority” from Marcos to sell the painting and receive the proceeds,
the defense emphasized; prosecutors question its legitimacy. At the
time, the work was not on the Philippines’ list of allegedly missing
paintings, though the government now seeks its return.
Bautista’s lawyer said the aide sold the painting for Marcos but never had a chance to give her the money.
Officials
at Zimbabwe's main art gallery say six African artifacts stolen in 2006
are back on display after a "sting" operation in Poland by FBI and CIA
law enforcement agents.
National
Art Gallery curator Lillian Chaonwa said Friday a suspect tried to sell
the art to an unnamed American buyer who alerted U.S. authorities. She
said a man convicted of the theft has since been jailed.
The
artifacts included two tribal face masks and four intricately carved
wooden headrests from the early 20th Century believed to have had
mystical properties during sleep.
Chaonwa said African museums
were being targeted by thieves knowing the value and rarity of the
continent's works of art to collectors.
She had posted images of the missing works on the Internet.
Police recover historic firearms stolen from Queen Victoria Museum and Art Gallery
Police have recovered two firearms stolen from the Queen Victoria Museum and Art Gallery. Source: Mercury
TWO antique pistols stolen from the Queen Victoria Museum and Art
Gallery have been discovered buried at a location just outside
Launceston.
The search was one of eight conducted over the past seven days in
relation to the theft with police using a metal detector during some of
the searches.
No charges have yet been laid in relation to the recovery of the pistols.
The
two revolver-style pistols dating from the 1860s were stolen on October
4. One is understood to have belonged to bushranger Martin Cash.
A
22-year-old Ravenswood man has been charged in relation to an
unregistered and illegally shortened .410 shotgun recovered in one of
the other searches. He will appear in the Launceston Magistrates Court
at a later date.
No claim has been made in relation to the $5000 reward offered by the Launceston City Council.
Lawyer cleared over stolen Leonardo da Vinci painting drops legal claim against police
Marshall Ronald originally raised a case against both the Duke of
Buccleuch and a Scottish police force seeking £4.25 million. and a
Scottish police force seeking £4.25 million.
The Madonna of the Yarnwinder
A lawyer who was struck off has dropped a legal claim against police authorities following the theft and
recovery of a Leonardo da Vinci painting stolen from a castle. But Marshall Ronald is still pursuing an action against the Duke of Buccleuch after a judge ruled it would not
be fair to dismiss it at this stage in proceedings.
Mr Ronald originally raised a case against both the duke and a
Scottish police force seeking £4.25 million after a judge ruled it would
not
be fair to dismiss it at this stage in proceedings.
He
was acquitted with others of a conspiracy to extort £4.25 million for
the safe return of the masterpiece at a trial at the High Court in
Edinburgh in 2010.
The valuable artwork, the Madonna of the Yarnwinder, was stolen from
the duke’s Drumlanrig Castle, in Dumfriesshire, in August 2003.
A
covert operation eventually led to the recovery of the painting
following a meeting at the offices of a Glasgow law firm on October 4 in
2007. Mr Ronald and others who had attended were detained.
Mr
Ronald, of Skelmersdale, Lancashire, subsequently raised an action at
the Court of Session in Edinburgh claiming that he was owed payment for
the return of the painting. Lawyers acting for the duke maintained that
he had not entered into any contract with Mr Ronald.
A
two-day procedural debate was due to begin today with the duke’s counsel
Andrew Young QC telling Lord Uist that Mr Ronald had abandoned his
action against the second defender, the police.
Mr
Young moved the court to dismiss the case against his client on a
technical legal issue. Mr Ronald opposed the motion. Lord Uist felt it
would be unfair to dismiss and continued the case.
Six stolen post-Byzantine icons recovered by the Church
Six post-Byzantine icons stolen from churches in the north after the Turkish invasion are to be repatriated.
The icons were found at P. Von Culmer art gallery, in Augsburg, Germany, in December 2010.
They are the icons of Saint Photini of 1811, Saint Panteleimonas of
1812, Apostle Andreas of the 18th century, Apostle Markos of the 18th
century, Agios Panteleimonas of 1854 and the icon of “Vaiforos” of the
18th century.
According to a press release issued by the Representation of the
Church of Cyprus to the European Union there have been indications that
these six icons were part of Turkish art dealer Aydin Dikmen’s Cypriot
loot. Dikmen has looted dozens of churches in the Turkish occupied part
of Cyprus.
After the identification of the icons, complains were lodged in cooperation with the Cypriot police authorities to the German police authorities, which confiscated them from Von Culmer.
This was followed by a successful effort for an out-of-court settlement, as the German authorities
advised, and so on October 9 Bishop of Neapolis Porfyrios travelled to
Munich and was handed over the six icons from German Police officer
Johann Hoffmann.
German lawyer Enno Engbers contributed to efforts to repatriate the icons.
POLICE
in India have confirmed a 1000-year-old statue on display at the Art
Gallery of NSW was stolen from a temple in southern India, most likely
in 2002, increasing the likelihood that a slew of antiquities in
Australia's pre-eminent art galleries will have to be surrendered.
AGNSW director Michael Brand has also confirmed his gallery
has joined the National Gallery of Australia in officially co-operating
with the international investigation into alleged antiquities-smuggling
mastermind Subhash Kapoor.
- See more at:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/arts/visual-arts/agnsw-statue-stolen-from-temple/story-fn9d3avm-1226736454533#sthash.1iIPR2aD.dpuf
POLICE
in India have confirmed a 1000-year-old statue on display at the Art
Gallery of NSW was stolen from a temple in southern India, most likely
in 2002, increasing the likelihood that a slew of antiquities in
Australia's pre-eminent art galleries will have to be surrendered.
AGNSW director Michael Brand has also confirmed his gallery
has joined the National Gallery of Australia in officially co-operating
with the international investigation into alleged antiquities-smuggling
mastermind Subhash Kapoor.
- See more at:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/arts/visual-arts/agnsw-statue-stolen-from-temple/story-fn9d3avm-1226736454533#sthash.1iIPR2aD.dpuf
No comments:
Post a Comment